Staging Real data, but not the live site β€” MFL writes, push and chat posts are switched off here.

Keeper Report Card

Every 2025 roster, re-ranked by 2026 points. The highlighted rows are the keeps that were actually worth a slot β€” up to seven, and often fewer. Hindsight is undefeated. Filed accordingly.

Points through Week 9 Β· Data as of Nov 10 4:09 PM PT

Best keeper class Chatmaster 97% of optimal 610.6 keeper pts Β· 6/7 hits
Worst keeper decisions Jewpacabra 57% of optimal 534.5 keeper pts Β· 3/7 hits
League-wide 104 hits Β· 64 misses 64 optimal keepers got away
Chatmaster icon

Chatmaster

6/7 hits
NL D-League 97% of optimal Β· #1 class Β· 610.6 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Tony Pollard headshot
Tony Pollard
RB
116.5 Kept Hit
2
Colston Loveland headshot
Colston Loveland
TE
101.8 Kept Hit
3
Jalen Hurts headshot
Jalen Hurts
QB
96.0 Kept Hit
4
Dallas Goedert headshot
Dallas Goedert
TE
89.5 Kept Hit
5
SEA logo
Seattle Seahawks
DEF
84.2 Got away
6
Mark Andrews headshot
Mark Andrews
TE
74.2 Kept Hit
7
DeVonta Smith headshot
DeVonta Smith
WR
69.0 Kept Hit
8
Courtland Sutton headshot
Courtland Sutton
WR
63.6 Kept Miss
Show full roster (9 more)
9
Darren Waller headshot
Darren Waller
TE
62.8
10
Tyjae Spears headshot
Tyjae Spears
RB
27.1
11
Jordan Mason headshot
Jordan Mason
RB
26.9
12
Zach Charbonnet headshot
Zach Charbonnet
RB
15.5
13
Kaleb Johnson headshot
Kaleb Johnson
RB
10.6
14
Kenneth Gainwell headshot
Kenneth Gainwell
RB
10.3
15
Wil Lutz headshot
Wil Lutz
PK
0.0
16
Jauan Jennings headshot
Jauan Jennings
WR
0.0
17
Audric Estime headshot
Audric Estime
RB
0.0
Fullybaked icon

Fullybaked

5/7 hits
AL D-League 95% of optimal Β· #2 class Β· 922.7 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Josh Allen headshot
Josh Allen
QB
223.7 Kept Hit
2
Christian Watson headshot
Christian Watson
WR
176.9 Kept Hit
3
Bucky Irving headshot
Bucky Irving
RB
159.1 Kept Hit
4
Amon-Ra St. Brown headshot
Amon-Ra St. Brown
WR
157.6 Kept Hit
5
Dallas Goedert headshot
Dallas Goedert
TE
89.5 Got away
6
Jake Bates headshot
Jake Bates
PK
82.8 Got away
7
Jaylen Waddle headshot
Jaylen Waddle
WR
82.0 Kept Hit
9
DK Metcalf headshot
DK Metcalf
WR
77.9 Kept Miss
13
David Montgomery headshot
David Montgomery
RB
45.5 Kept Miss
Show full roster (8 more)
8
Keenan Allen headshot
Keenan Allen
WR
81.1
10
Darren Waller headshot
Darren Waller
TE
62.8
11
Chris Godwin headshot
Chris Godwin
WR
57.9
12
NEP logo
New England Patriots
DEF
55.2
14
Devin Singletary headshot
Devin Singletary
RB
20.6
15
Zach Charbonnet headshot
Zach Charbonnet
RB
15.5
16
Tank Dell headshot
Tank Dell
WR
5.5
17
Jalen McMillan headshot
Jalen McMillan
WR
0.0
Harambe icon

Harambe

5/7 hits
AL Premier League 95% of optimal Β· #3 class Β· 942.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Brock Purdy headshot
Brock Purdy
QB
205.3 Got away
2
Dak Prescott headshot
Dak Prescott
QB
199.4 Kept Miss
3
D'Andre Swift headshot
D'Andre Swift
RB
153.8 Kept Hit
4
Jonathan Taylor headshot
Jonathan Taylor
RB
153.6 Kept Hit
6
Malik Nabers headshot
Malik Nabers
WR
129.8 Kept Hit
7
Zay Flowers headshot
Zay Flowers
WR
127.5 Kept Hit
8
Tetairoa McMillan headshot
Tetairoa McMillan
WR
124.5 Kept Hit
9
Ka'imi Fairbairn headshot
Ka'imi Fairbairn
PK
100.9 Got away
17
Jordan Addison headshot
Jordan Addison
WR
53.9 Kept Miss
Show full roster (10 more)
5
Bo Nix headshot
Bo Nix
QB
152.8
10
Hunter Henry headshot
Hunter Henry
TE
96.1
11
Aaron Jones headshot
Aaron Jones
RB
82.9
12
Josh Downs headshot
Josh Downs
WR
75.1
13
Rachaad White headshot
Rachaad White
RB
69.7
14
TBB logo
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
DEF
60.6
15
Deebo Samuel headshot
Deebo Samuel
WR
60.4
16
Chigoziem Okonkwo headshot
Chigoziem Okonkwo
TE
56.4
18
Zach Ertz headshot
Zach Ertz
TE
2.4
19
Kayshon Boutte headshot
Kayshon Boutte
WR
0.0
Da Dangsters icon

Da Dangsters

6/7 hits
AL D-League 93% of optimal Β· #4 class Β· 738.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
James Cook headshot
James Cook
RB
148.4 Kept Hit
2
George Kittle headshot
George Kittle
TE
133.3 Kept Hit
3
Michael Wilson headshot
Michael Wilson
WR
120.7 Got away
4
Tucker Kraft headshot
Tucker Kraft
TE
108.4 Kept Hit
5
Justin Jefferson headshot
Justin Jefferson
WR
95.2 Kept Hit
6
Justin Herbert headshot
Justin Herbert
QB
92.6 Kept Hit
7
Nico Collins headshot
Nico Collins
WR
91.6 Kept Hit
10
DeVonta Smith headshot
DeVonta Smith
WR
69.0 Kept Miss
Show full roster (9 more)
8
Jacoby Brissett headshot
Jacoby Brissett
QB
73.6
9
Woody Marks headshot
Woody Marks
RB
70.9
11
Emanuel Wilson headshot
Emanuel Wilson
RB
65.3
12
D.J. Moore headshot
D.J. Moore
WR
59.5
13
Terry McLaurin headshot
Terry McLaurin
WR
46.0
14
DET logo
Detroit Lions
DEF
30.3
15
Cade Otton headshot
Cade Otton
TE
28.0
16
Cairo Santos headshot
Cairo Santos
PK
27.0
17
Tyrone Tracy headshot
Tyrone Tracy
RB
8.7
Mariachi Ninjas icon

Mariachi Ninjas

5/7 hits
NL Premier League 93% of optimal Β· #5 class Β· 1,178.3 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Jaxon Smith-Njigba headshot
Jaxon Smith-Njigba
WR
232.1 Kept Hit
2
Drake Maye headshot
Drake Maye
QB
215.2 Kept Hit
3
Jahmyr Gibbs headshot
Jahmyr Gibbs
RB
209.2 Kept Hit
5
Puka Nacua headshot
Puka Nacua
WR
173.6 Kept Hit
6
Kyren Williams headshot
Kyren Williams
RB
159.1 Got away
7
Jonathan Taylor headshot
Jonathan Taylor
RB
153.6 Kept Hit
8
Michael Wilson headshot
Michael Wilson
WR
120.7 Got away
11
Tyler Warren headshot
Tyler Warren
TE
103.1 Kept Miss
13
Nico Collins headshot
Nico Collins
WR
91.6 Kept Miss
Show full roster (10 more)
4
Jared Goff headshot
Jared Goff
QB
177.4
9
Rhamondre Stevenson headshot
Rhamondre Stevenson
RB
113.7
10
Tucker Kraft headshot
Tucker Kraft
TE
108.4
12
Spencer Shrader headshot
Spencer Shrader
PK
100.8
14
JAC logo
Jacksonville Jaguars
DEF
66.7
15
Evan McPherson headshot
Evan McPherson
PK
60.6
16
DET logo
Detroit Lions
DEF
30.3
17
Mike Gesicki headshot
Mike Gesicki
TE
26.5
18
Daniel Jones headshot
Daniel Jones
QB
0.0
19
Jalen McMillan headshot
Jalen McMillan
WR
0.0
Ditkas icon

Ditkas

5/7 hits
AL D-League 88% of optimal Β· #6 class Β· 783.1 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Drake Maye headshot
Drake Maye
QB
215.2 Kept Hit
2
Javonte Williams headshot
Javonte Williams
RB
159.6 Kept Hit
3
Bhayshul Tuten headshot
Bhayshul Tuten
RB
127.2 Kept Hit
4
Harold Fannin headshot
Harold Fannin
TE
120.8 Kept Hit
5
Stefon Diggs headshot
Stefon Diggs
WR
90.3 Got away
6
Rome Odunze headshot
Rome Odunze
WR
88.8 Kept Hit
7
Cam Little headshot
Cam Little
PK
86.2 Got away
10
Omarion Hampton headshot
Omarion Hampton
RB
68.2 Kept Miss
13
Jaxson Dart headshot
Jaxson Dart
QB
33.4 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (11 more)
8
SEA logo
Seattle Seahawks
DEF
84.2
9
Khalil Shakir headshot
Khalil Shakir
WR
76.2
11
RJ Harvey headshot
RJ Harvey
RB
67.4
12
Jacory Croskey-Merritt headshot
Jacory Croskey-Merritt
RB
44.9
14
Jerry Jeudy headshot
Jerry Jeudy
WR
33.1
15
Dylan Sampson headshot
Dylan Sampson
RB
20.7
16
Kenneth Gainwell headshot
Kenneth Gainwell
RB
10.3
17
Gunnar Helm headshot
Gunnar Helm
TE
8.8
18
Troy Franklin headshot
Troy Franklin
WR
0.0
19
Theo Johnson headshot
Theo Johnson
TE
0.0
20
Konata Mumpfield headshot
Konata Mumpfield
WR
0.0
Micks icon

Micks

5/7 hits
NL D-League 85% of optimal Β· #7 class Β· 801.4 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Ja'Marr Chase headshot
Ja'Marr Chase
WR
159.7 Kept Hit
2
Bucky Irving headshot
Bucky Irving
RB
159.1 Kept Hit
3
C.J. Stroud headshot
C.J. Stroud
QB
144.9 Got away
4
Malik Nabers headshot
Malik Nabers
WR
129.8 Kept Hit
5
Zay Flowers headshot
Zay Flowers
WR
127.5 Got away
6
Harold Fannin headshot
Harold Fannin
TE
120.8 Kept Hit
7
Jameson Williams headshot
Jameson Williams
WR
105.7 Kept Hit
9
Justin Herbert headshot
Justin Herbert
QB
92.6 Kept Miss
14
Brian Thomas Jr. headshot
Brian Thomas Jr.
WR
33.7 Kept Miss
Show full roster (9 more)
8
Braelon Allen headshot
Braelon Allen
RB
101.0
10
Jason Myers headshot
Jason Myers
PK
82.4
11
NEP logo
New England Patriots
DEF
55.2
12
Tyler Allgeier headshot
Tyler Allgeier
RB
54.6
13
Jacory Croskey-Merritt headshot
Jacory Croskey-Merritt
RB
44.9
15
Michael Pittman headshot
Michael Pittman
WR
15.9
16
IND logo
Indianapolis Colts
DEF
0.0
17
Isiah Pacheco headshot
Isiah Pacheco
RB
0.0
18
Kayshon Boutte headshot
Kayshon Boutte
WR
0.0
Balls Deep icon

Balls Deep

6/7 hits
NL Premier League 85% of optimal Β· #8 class Β· 870.4 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Dak Prescott headshot
Dak Prescott
QB
199.4 Got away
2
Trey McBride headshot
Trey McBride
TE
199.3 Kept Hit
3
Bijan Robinson headshot
Bijan Robinson
RB
180.0 Kept Hit
5
Brock Bowers headshot
Brock Bowers
TE
170.0 Kept Hit
6
Garrett Wilson headshot
Garrett Wilson
WR
113.7 Kept Hit
7
Mike Evans headshot
Mike Evans
WR
89.0 Kept Hit
8
DK Metcalf headshot
DK Metcalf
WR
77.9 Kept Hit
12
Chris Godwin headshot
Chris Godwin
WR
57.9 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (12 more)
4
Matthew Stafford headshot
Matthew Stafford
QB
174.9
9
Khalil Shakir headshot
Khalil Shakir
WR
76.2
10
Tyler Loop headshot
Tyler Loop
PK
74.1
11
Devaughn Vele headshot
Devaughn Vele
WR
69.6
13
LAR logo
Los Angeles Rams
DEF
56.2
14
Keon Coleman headshot
Keon Coleman
WR
34.4
15
Dylan Sampson headshot
Dylan Sampson
RB
20.7
16
DAL logo
Dallas Cowboys
DEF
0.5
17
Ricky Pearsall headshot
Ricky Pearsall
WR
0.0
18
Adonai Mitchell headshot
Adonai Mitchell
WR
0.0
19
Devin Neal headshot
Devin Neal
RB
0.0
20
Tez Johnson headshot
Tez Johnson
WR
0.0
Drunk Indians icon

Drunk Indians

4/7 hits
AL Premier League 83% of optimal Β· #9 class Β· 925.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Kenneth Walker III headshot
Kenneth Walker III
RB
196.4 Kept Hit
2
Trevor Lawrence headshot
Trevor Lawrence
QB
183.2 Got away
3
Christian McCaffrey headshot
Christian McCaffrey
RB
166.7 Kept Hit
4
Ja'Marr Chase headshot
Ja'Marr Chase
WR
159.7 Kept Hit
5
Isaiah Likely headshot
Isaiah Likely
TE
151.8 Got away
6
Derrick Henry headshot
Derrick Henry
RB
142.3 Kept Hit
7
Parker Washington headshot
Parker Washington
WR
109.6 Got away
8
Tyler Warren headshot
Tyler Warren
TE
103.1 Kept Miss
9
Lamar Jackson headshot
Lamar Jackson
QB
91.1 Kept Miss
13
Rashee Rice headshot
Rashee Rice
WR
66.2 Kept Miss
Show full roster (7 more)
10
Kyle Pitts headshot
Kyle Pitts
TE
83.5
11
Jason Myers headshot
Jason Myers
PK
82.4
12
Mark Andrews headshot
Mark Andrews
TE
74.2
14
LAR logo
Los Angeles Rams
DEF
56.2
15
Jordan Mason headshot
Jordan Mason
RB
26.9
16
Audric Estime headshot
Audric Estime
RB
0.0
17
Ricky Pearsall headshot
Ricky Pearsall
WR
0.0
Smokane FC icon

Smokane FC

5/7 hits
AL Premier League 83% of optimal Β· #10 class Β· 838.1 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Jahmyr Gibbs headshot
Jahmyr Gibbs
RB
209.2 Kept Hit
2
Tyler Shough headshot
Tyler Shough
QB
173.6 Got away
3
Chris Olave headshot
Chris Olave
WR
141.4 Kept Hit
4
Luther Burden headshot
Luther Burden
WR
136.3 Kept Hit
6
Drake London headshot
Drake London
WR
121.6 Kept Hit
7
Travis Kelce headshot
Travis Kelce
TE
115.8 Got away
8
Garrett Wilson headshot
Garrett Wilson
WR
113.7 Kept Hit
11
Emeka Egbuka headshot
Emeka Egbuka
WR
78.0 Kept Miss
15
Breece Hall headshot
Breece Hall
RB
54.2 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (11 more)
5
Jayden Daniels headshot
Jayden Daniels
QB
129.2
9
Tyler Bass headshot
Tyler Bass
PK
98.2
10
Blake Corum headshot
Blake Corum
RB
94.6
12
Tyler Loop headshot
Tyler Loop
PK
74.1
13
Kyle Monangai headshot
Kyle Monangai
RB
59.3
14
Mason Taylor headshot
Mason Taylor
TE
55.7
16
Chris Rodriguez headshot
Chris Rodriguez
RB
36.1
17
Rashid Shaheed headshot
Rashid Shaheed
WR
24.0
18
Quentin Johnston headshot
Quentin Johnston
WR
18.1
19
LAC logo
Los Angeles Chargers
DEF
16.8
20
Daniel Jones headshot
Daniel Jones
QB
0.0
Vitside Mafia icon

Vitside Mafia

3/7 hits
AL Premier League 82% of optimal Β· #11 class Β· 859.0 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Joe Burrow headshot
Joe Burrow
QB
245.1 Got away
2
CeeDee Lamb headshot
CeeDee Lamb
WR
201.8 Kept Hit
3
Matthew Stafford headshot
Matthew Stafford
QB
174.9 Kept Miss
4
Kyren Williams headshot
Kyren Williams
RB
159.1 Kept Hit
5
Rhamondre Stevenson headshot
Rhamondre Stevenson
RB
113.7 Got away
6
Sam LaPorta headshot
Sam LaPorta
TE
110.6 Got away
7
Tre Tucker headshot
Tre Tucker
WR
109.3 Got away
8
Davante Adams headshot
Davante Adams
WR
102.0 Kept Hit
9
Chase Brown headshot
Chase Brown
RB
101.4 Kept Miss
10
Dalton Schultz headshot
Dalton Schultz
TE
88.9 Kept Miss
13
Travis Etienne headshot
Travis Etienne
RB
30.9 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
11
Courtland Sutton headshot
Courtland Sutton
WR
63.6
12
Evan McPherson headshot
Evan McPherson
PK
60.6
14
Jayden Reed headshot
Jayden Reed
WR
6.4
15
MIA logo
Miami Dolphins
DEF
0.0
16
Jonnu Smith headshot
Jonnu Smith
TE
0.0
17
Joe Flacco headshot
Joe Flacco
QB
0.0
The Show icon

The Show

3/7 hits
NL D-League 82% of optimal Β· #12 class Β· 572.4 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Tee Higgins headshot
Tee Higgins
WR
159.8 Kept Hit
2
Ashton Jeanty headshot
Ashton Jeanty
RB
139.3 Kept Hit
3
Hunter Henry headshot
Hunter Henry
TE
96.1 Kept Hit
4
Kyler Murray headshot
Kyler Murray
QB
83.6 Got away
5
Josh Downs headshot
Josh Downs
WR
75.1 Got away
6
Sam Darnold headshot
Sam Darnold
QB
74.8 Kept Miss
7
AJ Barner headshot
AJ Barner
TE
74.3 Got away
8
DEN logo
Denver Broncos
DEF
71.0 Got away
10
Kyle Monangai headshot
Kyle Monangai
RB
59.3 Kept Miss
11
Travis Etienne headshot
Travis Etienne
RB
30.9 Kept Miss
14
Alec Pierce headshot
Alec Pierce
WR
12.2 Kept Miss
Show full roster (8 more)
9
Cameron Dicker headshot
Cameron Dicker
PK
66.0
12
Quentin Johnston headshot
Quentin Johnston
WR
18.1
13
Kimani Vidal headshot
Kimani Vidal
RB
16.6
15
Tyreek Hill headshot
Tyreek Hill
WR
0.0
16
Calvin Ridley headshot
Calvin Ridley
WR
0.0
17
Trey Benson headshot
Trey Benson
RB
0.0
18
Isaiah Davis headshot
Isaiah Davis
RB
0.0
19
Joe Flacco headshot
Joe Flacco
QB
0.0
Computer Jocks icon

Computer Jocks

3/7 hits
AL Premier League 81% of optimal Β· #13 class Β· 564.6 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Brock Bowers headshot
Brock Bowers
TE
170.0 Kept Hit
2
Patrick Mahomes headshot
Patrick Mahomes
QB
170.0 Kept Hit
3
Jameson Williams headshot
Jameson Williams
WR
105.7 Kept Hit
4
Brenton Strange headshot
Brenton Strange
TE
86.6 Got away
6
J.K. Dobbins headshot
J.K. Dobbins
RB
62.5 Got away
7
Tyler Allgeier headshot
Tyler Allgeier
RB
54.6 Got away
8
HOU logo
Houston Texans
DEF
45.3 Got away
9
Rico Dowdle headshot
Rico Dowdle
RB
44.6 Kept Miss
10
TreVeyon Henderson headshot
TreVeyon Henderson
RB
33.8 Kept Miss
12
De'Von Achane headshot
De'Von Achane
RB
24.6 Kept Miss
13
Michael Pittman headshot
Michael Pittman
WR
15.9 Kept Miss
Show full roster (12 more)
5
Sam Darnold headshot
Sam Darnold
QB
74.8
11
Brian Robinson headshot
Brian Robinson
RB
30.3
14
Kendre Miller headshot
Kendre Miller
RB
14.8
15
Chris Boswell headshot
Chris Boswell
PK
9.7
16
Oronde Gadsden headshot
Oronde Gadsden
TE
6.2
17
Jaylen Wright headshot
Jaylen Wright
RB
3.1
18
Najee Harris headshot
Najee Harris
RB
0.2
19
Nick Chubb headshot
Nick Chubb
RB
0.0
20
Brandon Aiyuk headshot
Brandon Aiyuk
WR
0.0
21
Michael Carter headshot
Michael Carter
RB
0.0
22
Bam Knight headshot
Bam Knight
RB
0.0
23
Adonai Mitchell headshot
Adonai Mitchell
WR
0.0
Suh girls icon

Suh girls

4/7 hits
AL Premier League 80% of optimal Β· #14 class Β· 723.4 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Trey McBride headshot
Trey McBride
TE
199.3 Kept Hit
2
C.J. Stroud headshot
C.J. Stroud
QB
144.9 Got away
3
Jaylen Warren headshot
Jaylen Warren
RB
140.8 Kept Hit
4
Ashton Jeanty headshot
Ashton Jeanty
RB
139.3 Kept Hit
5
MIN logo
Minnesota Vikings
DEF
106.1 Got away
6
Jalen Hurts headshot
Jalen Hurts
QB
96.0 Kept Miss
7
Juwan Johnson headshot
Juwan Johnson
TE
92.9 Got away
8
Wan'Dale Robinson headshot
Wan'Dale Robinson
WR
77.3 Kept Hit
10
Ladd McConkey headshot
Ladd McConkey
WR
51.6 Kept Miss
13
A.J. Brown headshot
A.J. Brown
WR
19.1 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
9
Pat Freiermuth headshot
Pat Freiermuth
TE
73.4
11
Romeo Doubs headshot
Romeo Doubs
WR
45.5
12
Mike Gesicki headshot
Mike Gesicki
TE
26.5
14
Tank Bigsby headshot
Tank Bigsby
RB
17.1
15
Kimani Vidal headshot
Kimani Vidal
RB
16.6
16
Andres Borregales headshot
Andres Borregales
PK
9.4
Swiftie 4 Life icon

Swiftie 4 Life

5/7 hits
NL D-League 79% of optimal Β· #15 class Β· 840.8 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Joe Burrow headshot
Joe Burrow
QB
245.1 Kept Hit
2
CeeDee Lamb headshot
CeeDee Lamb
WR
201.8 Kept Hit
3
Javonte Williams headshot
Javonte Williams
RB
159.6 Kept Hit
4
D'Andre Swift headshot
D'Andre Swift
RB
153.8 Got away
5
George Kittle headshot
George Kittle
TE
133.3 Kept Hit
6
Brandon Aubrey headshot
Brandon Aubrey
PK
88.9 Kept Hit
8
Aaron Jones headshot
Aaron Jones
RB
82.9 Got away
11
Baker Mayfield headshot
Baker Mayfield
QB
56.9 Kept Miss Bench
16
Jayden Reed headshot
Jayden Reed
WR
6.4 Kept Miss
Show full roster (10 more)
7
Cam Little headshot
Cam Little
PK
86.2
9
Keenan Allen headshot
Keenan Allen
WR
81.1
10
Pat Freiermuth headshot
Pat Freiermuth
TE
73.4
12
KCC logo
Kansas City Chiefs
DEF
46.5
13
Romeo Doubs headshot
Romeo Doubs
WR
45.5
14
Tyler Higbee headshot
Tyler Higbee
TE
30.5
15
BUF logo
Buffalo Bills
DEF
29.4
17
Miles Sanders headshot
Miles Sanders
RB
0.0
18
Justice Hill headshot
Justice Hill
RB
0.0
19
Xavier Legette headshot
Xavier Legette
WR
0.0
Badd Boys icon

Badd Boys

5/7 hits
NL Premier League 79% of optimal Β· #16 class Β· 590.6 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Bo Nix headshot
Bo Nix
QB
152.8 Got away
2
James Cook headshot
James Cook
RB
148.4 Kept Hit
4
George Pickens headshot
George Pickens
WR
104.3 Kept Hit
5
Davante Adams headshot
Davante Adams
WR
102.0 Kept Hit
6
Juwan Johnson headshot
Juwan Johnson
TE
92.9 Got away
7
Kyle Pitts headshot
Kyle Pitts
TE
83.5 Kept Hit
8
RJ Harvey headshot
RJ Harvey
RB
67.4 Kept Hit
11
Saquon Barkley headshot
Saquon Barkley
RB
58.7 Kept Miss
13
Marvin Harrison Jr. headshot
Marvin Harrison Jr.
WR
37.5 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (8 more)
3
Bryce Young headshot
Bryce Young
QB
111.1
9
TBB logo
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
DEF
60.6
10
Deebo Samuel headshot
Deebo Samuel
WR
60.4
12
Rico Dowdle headshot
Rico Dowdle
RB
44.6
14
PHI logo
Philadelphia Eagles
DEF
21.7
15
Andres Borregales headshot
Andres Borregales
PK
9.4
16
Oronde Gadsden headshot
Oronde Gadsden
TE
6.2
17
James Conner headshot
James Conner
RB
0.0
Bruin Pegs Me icon

Bruin Pegs Me

4/7 hits
NL D-League 78% of optimal Β· #17 class Β· 657.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Matthew Golden headshot
Matthew Golden
WR
163.9 Got away
2
Chuba Hubbard headshot
Chuba Hubbard
RB
146.6 Kept Hit
3
Bhayshul Tuten headshot
Bhayshul Tuten
RB
127.2 Kept Hit
4
Caleb Williams headshot
Caleb Williams
QB
126.3 Kept Hit
5
Blake Corum headshot
Blake Corum
RB
94.6 Got away
6
Quinshon Judkins headshot
Quinshon Judkins
RB
92.1 Kept Hit
7
Stefon Diggs headshot
Stefon Diggs
WR
90.3 Got away
9
Omarion Hampton headshot
Omarion Hampton
RB
68.2 Kept Miss
11
Ladd McConkey headshot
Ladd McConkey
WR
51.6 Kept Miss
12
David Montgomery headshot
David Montgomery
RB
45.5 Kept Miss
Show full roster (9 more)
8
Woody Marks headshot
Woody Marks
RB
70.9
10
Eddy Pineiro headshot
Eddy Pineiro
PK
54.5
13
Colby Parkinson headshot
Colby Parkinson
TE
44.6
14
CHI logo
Chicago Bears
DEF
36.9
15
Tyrone Tracy headshot
Tyrone Tracy
RB
8.7
16
Zach Ertz headshot
Zach Ertz
TE
2.4
17
Kareem Hunt headshot
Kareem Hunt
RB
0.0
18
Brandon Aiyuk headshot
Brandon Aiyuk
WR
0.0
19
Troy Franklin headshot
Troy Franklin
WR
0.0
Minty Fresh icon

Minty Fresh

4/7 hits
AL D-League 78% of optimal Β· #18 class Β· 596.9 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Tee Higgins headshot
Tee Higgins
WR
159.8 Kept Hit
2
Chuba Hubbard headshot
Chuba Hubbard
RB
146.6 Got away
3
Chase McLaughlin headshot
Chase McLaughlin
PK
106.1 Got away
4
George Pickens headshot
George Pickens
WR
104.3 Kept Hit
5
Colston Loveland headshot
Colston Loveland
TE
101.8 Kept Hit
6
Jakobi Meyers headshot
Jakobi Meyers
WR
75.6 Kept Hit
7
Alvin Kamara headshot
Alvin Kamara
RB
73.7 Got away
8
Cam Skattebo headshot
Cam Skattebo
RB
70.4 Kept Miss
10
Saquon Barkley headshot
Saquon Barkley
RB
58.7 Kept Miss
11
Marvin Harrison Jr. headshot
Marvin Harrison Jr.
WR
37.5 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (7 more)
9
JAC logo
Jacksonville Jaguars
DEF
66.7
12
David Njoku headshot
David Njoku
TE
2.4
13
Geno Smith headshot
Geno Smith
QB
0.0
14
Justin Fields headshot
Justin Fields
QB
0.0
15
Jerome Ford headshot
Jerome Ford
RB
0.0
16
Jake Tonges headshot
Jake Tonges
TE
0.0
17
Jayden Higgins headshot
Jayden Higgins
WR
0.0
Titsburgh icon

Titsburgh

4/7 hits
NL Premier League 75% of optimal Β· #19 class Β· 668.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Josh Allen headshot
Josh Allen
QB
223.7 Kept Hit
2
Christian McCaffrey headshot
Christian McCaffrey
RB
166.7 Kept Hit
3
Travis Kelce headshot
Travis Kelce
TE
115.8 Got away
4
Parker Washington headshot
Parker Washington
WR
109.6 Kept Hit
5
Chase Brown headshot
Chase Brown
RB
101.4 Kept Hit
6
Dalton Schultz headshot
Dalton Schultz
TE
88.9 Got away
7
Jaylen Waddle headshot
Jaylen Waddle
WR
82.0 Got away
10
Terry McLaurin headshot
Terry McLaurin
WR
46.0 Kept Miss
12
Devin Singletary headshot
Devin Singletary
RB
20.6 Kept Miss
14
Travis Hunter headshot
Travis Hunter
WR
0.5 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
8
Wan'Dale Robinson headshot
Wan'Dale Robinson
WR
77.3
9
Jakobi Meyers headshot
Jakobi Meyers
WR
75.6
11
NOS logo
New Orleans Saints
DEF
33.6
13
Chris Boswell headshot
Chris Boswell
PK
9.7
15
Bam Knight headshot
Bam Knight
RB
0.0
16
Cam Ward headshot
Cam Ward
QB
0.0
Midwestside icon

Midwestside

3/7 hits
AL Premier League 71% of optimal Β· #20 class Β· 604.3 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Jaxon Smith-Njigba headshot
Jaxon Smith-Njigba
WR
232.1 Kept Hit
2
Caleb Williams headshot
Caleb Williams
QB
126.3 Kept Hit
3
Tony Pollard headshot
Tony Pollard
RB
116.5 Got away
4
T.J. Hockenson headshot
T.J. Hockenson
TE
103.3 Got away
5
Quinshon Judkins headshot
Quinshon Judkins
RB
92.1 Kept Hit
6
Mike Evans headshot
Mike Evans
WR
89.0 Got away
7
Brandon Aubrey headshot
Brandon Aubrey
PK
88.9 Got away
8
Jake Ferguson headshot
Jake Ferguson
TE
64.1 Kept Miss
10
Josh Jacobs headshot
Josh Jacobs
RB
43.8 Kept Miss
11
Brian Thomas Jr. headshot
Brian Thomas Jr.
WR
33.7 Kept Miss
14
Alec Pierce headshot
Alec Pierce
WR
12.2 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
9
Baker Mayfield headshot
Baker Mayfield
QB
56.9
12
NOS logo
New Orleans Saints
DEF
33.6
13
PHI logo
Philadelphia Eagles
DEF
21.7
15
Travis Hunter headshot
Travis Hunter
WR
0.5
16
Darius Slayton headshot
Darius Slayton
WR
0.0
17
Cam Ward headshot
Cam Ward
QB
0.0
Boondock Saints icon

Boondock Saints

3/7 hits
NL D-League 71% of optimal Β· #21 class Β· 660.0 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Kenneth Walker III headshot
Kenneth Walker III
RB
196.4 Kept Hit
2
Christian Watson headshot
Christian Watson
WR
176.9 Got away
3
Patrick Mahomes headshot
Patrick Mahomes
QB
170.0 Got away
4
Derrick Henry headshot
Derrick Henry
RB
142.3 Kept Hit
5
Jayden Daniels headshot
Jayden Daniels
QB
129.2 Kept Miss
6
Rome Odunze headshot
Rome Odunze
WR
88.8 Got away
7
Jake Bates headshot
Jake Bates
PK
82.8 Got away
8
Emeka Egbuka headshot
Emeka Egbuka
WR
78.0 Kept Hit
10
Cam Skattebo headshot
Cam Skattebo
RB
70.4 Kept Miss
15
De'Von Achane headshot
De'Von Achane
RB
24.6 Kept Miss
16
A.J. Brown headshot
A.J. Brown
WR
19.1 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
9
Jacoby Brissett headshot
Jacoby Brissett
QB
73.6
11
Xavier Worthy headshot
Xavier Worthy
WR
66.8
12
Ollie Gordon II headshot
Ollie Gordon II
RB
64.4
13
CLE logo
Cleveland Browns
DEF
38.6
14
Evan Engram headshot
Evan Engram
TE
32.1
17
Jaylen Wright headshot
Jaylen Wright
RB
3.1
No Soup For You icon

No Soup For You

4/7 hits
NL Premier League 68% of optimal Β· #22 class Β· 627.3 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Jordan Love headshot
Jordan Love
QB
223.0 Got away
3
Jaylen Warren headshot
Jaylen Warren
RB
140.8 Got away
4
Luther Burden headshot
Luther Burden
WR
136.3 Kept Hit
5
Drake London headshot
Drake London
WR
121.6 Kept Hit
6
Sam LaPorta headshot
Sam LaPorta
TE
110.6 Kept Hit
7
Ka'imi Fairbairn headshot
Ka'imi Fairbairn
PK
100.9 Got away
8
Justin Jefferson headshot
Justin Jefferson
WR
95.2 Kept Hit
12
Rashee Rice headshot
Rashee Rice
WR
66.2 Kept Miss
16
D.J. Moore headshot
D.J. Moore
WR
59.5 Kept Miss
19
Breece Hall headshot
Breece Hall
RB
54.2 Kept Miss Bench
Show full roster (15 more)
2
Tyler Shough headshot
Tyler Shough
QB
173.6
9
Lamar Jackson headshot
Lamar Jackson
QB
91.1
10
Brenton Strange headshot
Brenton Strange
TE
86.6
11
Alvin Kamara headshot
Alvin Kamara
RB
73.7
13
Jake Ferguson headshot
Jake Ferguson
TE
64.1
14
J.K. Dobbins headshot
J.K. Dobbins
RB
62.5
15
Michael Mayer headshot
Michael Mayer
TE
60.6
17
SFO logo
San Francisco 49ers
DEF
56.3
18
Mason Taylor headshot
Mason Taylor
TE
55.7
20
GBP logo
Green Bay Packers
DEF
35.8
21
Jerry Jeudy headshot
Jerry Jeudy
WR
33.1
22
Jonathon Brooks headshot
Jonathon Brooks
RB
9.3
23
Raheim Sanders headshot
Raheim Sanders
RB
5.9
24
Theo Johnson headshot
Theo Johnson
TE
0.0
25
Kyle Williams headshot
Kyle Williams
WR
0.0
Avenging Amish icon

Avenging Amish

4/7 hits
AL D-League 62% of optimal Β· #23 class Β· 520.3 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Bijan Robinson headshot
Bijan Robinson
RB
180.0 Kept Hit
2
Jared Goff headshot
Jared Goff
QB
177.4 Got away
3
Puka Nacua headshot
Puka Nacua
WR
173.6 Kept Hit
4
Dalton Kincaid headshot
Dalton Kincaid
TE
99.9 Kept Hit
5
AJ Barner headshot
AJ Barner
TE
74.3 Got away
6
DEN logo
Denver Broncos
DEF
71.0 Got away
7
Xavier Worthy headshot
Xavier Worthy
WR
66.8 Kept Hit
12
Joe Mixon headshot
Joe Mixon
RB
0.0 Kept Miss
14
James Conner headshot
James Conner
RB
0.0 Kept Miss
15
Austin Ekeler headshot
Austin Ekeler
RB
0.0 Kept Miss
Show full roster (9 more)
8
Cameron Dicker headshot
Cameron Dicker
PK
66.0
9
Rashod Bateman headshot
Rashod Bateman
WR
55.4
10
Ryan Flournoy headshot
Ryan Flournoy
WR
48.4
11
CHI logo
Chicago Bears
DEF
36.9
13
Kareem Hunt headshot
Kareem Hunt
RB
0.0
16
Jauan Jennings headshot
Jauan Jennings
WR
0.0
17
Cole Kmet headshot
Cole Kmet
TE
0.0
18
J.J. McCarthy headshot
J.J. McCarthy
QB
0.0
19
Tez Johnson headshot
Tez Johnson
WR
0.0
Jewpacabra icon

Jewpacabra

3/7 hits
NL D-League 57% of optimal Β· #24 class Β· 534.5 keeper pts
# Player Pts
1
Brock Purdy headshot
Brock Purdy
QB
205.3 Got away
3
Amon-Ra St. Brown headshot
Amon-Ra St. Brown
WR
157.6 Kept Hit
4
Chris Olave headshot
Chris Olave
WR
141.4 Kept Hit
5
Tetairoa McMillan headshot
Tetairoa McMillan
WR
124.5 Kept Hit
6
Chase McLaughlin headshot
Chase McLaughlin
PK
106.1 Got away
7
T.J. Hockenson headshot
T.J. Hockenson
TE
103.3 Got away
8
Dalton Kincaid headshot
Dalton Kincaid
TE
99.9 Got away
12
Josh Jacobs headshot
Josh Jacobs
RB
43.8 Kept Miss
13
TreVeyon Henderson headshot
TreVeyon Henderson
RB
33.8 Kept Miss
14
Jaxson Dart headshot
Jaxson Dart
QB
33.4 Kept Miss
17
Jayden Higgins headshot
Jayden Higgins
WR
0.0 Kept Miss
Show full roster (6 more)
2
Trevor Lawrence headshot
Trevor Lawrence
QB
183.2
9
PIT logo
Pittsburgh Steelers
DEF
86.4
10
Jordan Addison headshot
Jordan Addison
WR
53.9
11
HOU logo
Houston Texans
DEF
45.3
15
Geno Smith headshot
Geno Smith
QB
0.0
16
Joe Mixon headshot
Joe Mixon
RB
0.0

Methodology

How this is graded: a keeper is worth the points he scored in the games you could have started him. Every class is scored on % of optimal β€” the keeper points its keeps banked against the best seven that roster could have kept. That grades the decision, not the inheritance: maxing out a thin roster beats leaving points on a loaded one. Keeper points and hits are shown too, but the ranking is the percentage. Backup keeps aren't written off β€” they're credited the share of their points they'd realistically have played.

  • Points are 2026 regular-season fantasy points in AFL scoring, summed across the weeks a player was on a roster (MFL records scores for rostered players only, so unrostered stretches don't count). A kept player traded mid-season still credits his full season to the team that kept him. Totals update live during game weekends as the feeds refresh.
  • Keeper classes come straight from the post-deadline roster snapshot (2026-07-17) β€” between the keeper cut deadline and the draft, the roster is the keeper class.
  • The optimal seven are lineup-legal β€” one QB, one kicker, one defense and six from RB/WR/TE. A Hit means you kept one of the seven most valuable players your roster had: the guys who scored the most points in slots you could actually have started them in.
  • A keep who doesn't win a starting slot is a backup, and backups aren't written off β€” they're credited the share of their points they'd realistically have played. A seventh skill player rotates in across six flex starters' byes and matchups, so he counts 7/10 of his points; a second quarterback, kicker, or defense only plays the starter's bye week and the odd matchup call, so he counts 1/10. Those keeps are marked Bench. A third QB or an eighth skill player sits behind someone who already covers those games and counts for nothing.
  • A keep is only a miss when somebody better actually got away. If your roster only had four players worth keeping and you kept all four, the other slots were spent on nobody β€” that isn't a decision anyone got wrong, so it isn't counted against you. The hit tally is out of the calls that had a better answer available.
  • Classes rank on the share of their own ceiling they captured, not on raw totals β€” the ceiling swings about 2x across the league in a given cycle, and nobody chose the roster they inherited. Ties break on value captured, then franchise id.
  • A roster can be worth fewer than seven keeps β€” if only four players scored anything, the optimal set is four and the spare slots cost you nothing. Ties break by player id: hindsight is cruel but consistent.
  • Numbers come straight from the season's MFL feeds; the judgment is Claude Schefter's. Per source: the source is the box score.